These are the Streamlight Task-Lights, 1AA and 2AA.
The upper light is powered by a single AA cell and uses
a reflector and Nichia CS 5mm LED for light, while the
lower light uses a 0.5W Nichia Rigel high powered LED
with a special collimating lens and 2 AA cells. Both
lights have 3 different output settings: high, low,
and flash.
Body: Both lights have anodized aluminum bodies.
The head and tailcap have decorative rings machined
into them, while the bodies are checkered for grip.
The 1AA light has much more gentle checkering, similar
to a Maglite, while the 2AA light has a more aggressive
checkering giving it a better grip. The tailcap of both
lights is drilled for a split-ring attached lanyard
and has a vent in the center.
1AA Tailcap, 2AA tailcap
Bezel/Head: The head of both lights is larger
in diameter than the body and they are sealed so that
they cannot be opened without tools. The 1AA light has
a very deep reflector that houses the single 5mm LED,
while the 2AA light uses a large collimating lens.
1AA Bezel, 2AA Bezel
Output: The white light produced by the 1AA
LED is typical for a Nichia CS 5mm LED - it has a yellowish
beam with a bluish center. The beam has a distinct transition
between the central spot, corona, and spillbeam, giving
it a slightly ringy profile. The 2AA Rigel LED is visibly
purplish in tint. The beam has a fairly smooth transition
from one part of the beam to the next, with some rings
in the spillbeam.
The dim mode is achieved with the use of a PWM (Pulse
Width Modulation), which means the light is flickered
very rapidly to create the illusion of dimming. This
works as a result of a perceptual feature of our brain
called "persistence of vision". Basically,
our eyes can only pick up motion just so quickly and
this results in "gaps" in our visual field.
Our brain brain fills in those gaps so our vision does
not appear jittery. This is also why animation (movies,
TV, etc.) appears to be a continuous flow instead of
24 individual flickering frames per second.
You can detect a PWM dimmed light by moving it very
rapidly across your field of vision. You'll then usually
see the individual flickers. Reading with a PWM dimmed
light can be uncomfortable for some people because the
rapid movement of the eyes across the page makes the
flicker visible. Although the flicker can be annoying
at times, PWM dimmed lights are very good at battery
conservation because the light is actually "off"
some of the time (in-between the flickers).
Level
|
|
|
1AA High
|
73 (8.54)
|
400 (4.00)
|
1AA Low
|
14 (3.74)
|
77 (0.77)
|
2AA High
|
579 (24.06)
|
1500 (15.00)
|
2AA Low
|
120 (10.95)
|
300 (3.00)
|
All throw readings are in Lux
at one meter. The numbers in parenthesis are for comparison
in the Comparison
Charts.
1AA beam at one meter at target center and at target
edge to show spillbeam.
2AA beam at one meter at target center and at target
edge to show spillbeam.
Runtime Plot: Not bad at all. Fairly typical
semi-regulated output.
Runtime
completed with included Duracell brand batteries. More
information on runtime plots is available HERE.
Runtime
completed with included Duracell brand batteries. More
information on runtime plots is available HERE.
Switch: The switches are rubber covered electronic
clickies with no momentary option available. Press once
for high, again for low, again for off. Press and hold
until it starts blinking for the flashing mode. The
1AA switch is notably higher than the 2AA switch which
could make it prone to accidental activation.
1AA Switch, 2AA Switch
Seals / Water Resistance: O-ring seals protect
the ends of the light from the entry of water. It should
withstand a drop in a puddle without any trouble. If
it gets wet inside, just disassemble as much a possible
without tools and let it dry before using again.
Ergonomics: Not much to mention here. They are
easy to handle and use.
Size compared to a common 2AA aluminum light
Batteries: AA cells power these lights. The
instructions do not mention the use of any other battery
type than alkaline, so I'd avoid everything else.
A somewhat negative characteristic of these lights
is that the boost/switching circuit inside the light
is parasitic. It constantly draws current from the batteries
even with it turned off. The 1AA only draws 0.4mA, while
the 2AA draws about 2mA. This means that if the batteries
are left in the light, even with the light turned off,
in about 8 months the 1AA light's cell will dead, and
in less than 90 days the 2AA battery light will probably
have dead cells. As a result, these lights may be good
for situations where they will see fairly heavy use,
but should not be used as emergency lights with the
batteries left in them.
A parasitic circuit is especially bad for NiMH cells,
which are sensitive to over discharge, but even alkalines
are impacted since they tend to leak when overly drained.
Accessories: A nylon wrist lanyard in included
and comes attached to the light.
What I Liked: Water resistant,
Inherently impact resistant, Good battery life, Good
output, Easy battery change, Lightweight, Stands up
What I Didn't Like: Parasitic circuit
will drain the batteries even when the light is turned
off. You must remove the cells when storing the light
or not using it for long periods of time.
Picky Little Things:
Conclusions: Good general use lights,
provided they will see frequent use. Remove the batteries
when they are not being used for a significant period
of time or else they will become just another "dead
battery holder" for the back of your kitchen drawer.
|