Inova X1

Original review sample was provided
by the kind folks at:

 
 
4½ Stars
Very Good/Excellent
         

Light Type: LED
Light Class: Outdoor / General Use

UPDATE March 2006: New version with a reflector instead of an optics system was purchased at Target Department Store and the review has been updated, adding the new information to the old. The 4½ Star rating is for the new version. The older version, with an optics system instead of a reflector, rated 4 Stars due to its limited utility.

UPDATE April 2006: I just discovered that the Inova X1 (new version) has been recommended by world traveler Doug Dyment, publisher of OneBag.com as the flashlight of choice for travelers. In my opinion, he has made an excellent selection and it comes with my full support as well.

UPDATE May 2007: Danger, Will Robinson! Danger! Inova has come out with yet another version of the X1! They have gotten rid of the Nichia LED and replaced it with a Luxeon LXCL-PWT3, similar to this one. This change results in about twice the brightness, but our eyes work on a logrithmic scale, so a doubling of brightness isn't perceived as much of a change. The cost of this extra brightness is staggering. The light now has only about 20% of the runtime of the Nichia version! It now has a listed runtime of less than 2 hours. In my opinion Inova has taken this light a big step in the wrong direction.

Short Description:

The Inova X1 is made by Emissive Energy Corp.

The body of the Inova X1 is made of anodized aluminum with flat facets machined in the sides. The body finish is available in silver or black.

The X1 uses a single white 5mm LED for light. The original version of the X1 had a recessed anti-reflective coated convex lens at the front of the light, behind the stainless steel bezel ring. As of March 2006, you will find that this version is being phased out and replaced with a new version that has a reflector with a clear lens instead of an anti-reflective collimating lens. The LED and lens combination in the older, original model, produced a very round spotlight-style beam with absolutely no sidespill. This type of beam, in my opinion, severely limited the usefulness of the light. The new version produces a broad beam which provides excellent illumination properties and provides excellent utility.

It appears that the newer reflector version of this light is using a more powerful LED since it has almost the same throw as the original, despite the fact that it has a much wider beam. Overall output is over 4 times that of the original, lensed type.

The X1 is available with different colored LEDs including white, green, or blue. Inside the X1 is a regulation circuit designed to give good output for up to 10 hours from a single AA battery. The switch is contained in the tailcap which is also reverse checkered for grip and has a hole for lanyard attachment. Press for momentary light, tighten for constant on, loosen to disable the switch for travel and packing.


Original Package - Current package is slightly different

Detailed Information:

The body of the light is anodized aluminum with longitudinal flat panels machined into its sides to help with grip. The surface is very smooth with no real texture. The tailcap has reverse checkering for grip when twisting the switch. The very front of the light contains a stainless steel bezel with beveled edges. This bezel ring helps protect the recessed glass optics. The inside of the light is also anodized for corrosion resistance. Machining is very good. The fit and finish are excellent.


Size vs. common aluminum 2-AA light


Size Reference


New (bottom) vs. Old (top)

Inside the bezel behind the glass lens is a single 5mm white LED. In the new version of this light it is set in the middle of a metal polished reflector which catches the sidespill light and directs it forward. In the older version the LED is set at a precise distance from the optics to produce a very uniform and round circle of light. Further in is a regulator circuit which should give uniform light output over the life of the battery, which was advertised at about 10 hours.


Bezel picture - New version with reflector
on left, older version on right

The switch is basically identical to the Inova X5. There is a rubber dot in the center that can be pressed for momentary operation. Tighten the whole tailcap for constant operation. Turn back 1 full turn and the light is "locked out" - it cannot turn on. This setting is to prevent accidental operation which could wear down your battery in the bottom of your backpack or luggage.

Output from the reflector version is a wide spot of smooth light, brighter in the center, with a slight bluish tint. The optics version produces a very round and quite uniform spot with a bluish ring around the edge of the spot and a few minor beam artifacts.


Beam at one meter, New version left vs. Old version right (~ 7" diameter spot at one meter)


Direct comparison - new on left, old on right
I think you can see why I prefer the newer version!

Runtime Plot: Great runtime! Over 8 hours before it reaches 50% of its starting output. After that it keeps going for many more hours.


Runtime completed with included batteries. More information on runtime plots is available HERE.

The X1 is water resistant and is protected at the tailcap by an O-ring which should be kept clean and lubricated with a silicone grease.

The X1 is powered by a single AA alkaline battery. The use of any other type of AA battery (lithium or rechargeable) is not mentioned in the documentation and is therefore not recommended. Simply unscrew the tailcap and drop in a new battery, positive side first. There is a piston-based reverse polarity protection device built in to the far end of the light to protect the electronics.

What I Liked: Well engineered, tough little light. Lots of extras like the stainless steel bezel, coated optics and regulation circuitry.

What I Didn't Like: The one thing I really disliked about the older, optics-based version was the complete lack of sidespill. It was sort of like looking around a room through a hole in a sheet of paper held at arms length. You only get to see a small part of the picture at any moment in time which makes it very dangerous for navigation in the dark. Good for spotting, not so good for navigating. The new version with the reflector, which appears to be the now-current version as the older optics-based system lights are discontinued, provides a much better beam and is much more useful in my opinion.

Other Things I Noticed: The finish of the new reflector-based light I just picked up is slightly darker than the original.

Conclusions: A well engineered light with top quality components. I'd recommend looking for the new one if purchasing one around the time of this update (March 2006). The older ones will probably be phased out, so if you like the spotlight type of output, get them while you can. The new version was purchased from Target Department Stores. The review rating has been updated to reflect (pun intended) the improvements in the new version.


Quick Facts Table:

Item Reviewed.......................... Inova X1
Review Date ............................. November 2003 (Updated March 2006)
Case Material ........................... Anodized aluminum
Case Features .......................... Flat machined panels on sides, lanyard hole in tailcap
Case Access Type .................... Unscrew tailcap for battery change
Switch Type ............................. Press for momentary, tighten for constant on, loosen for lockout
Reflector Type ......................... None
Lens Type ................................

Clear glass or Anti-Reflective coated precision glass convex lens

Bulb Type ................................. 1 x 5mm LED
Beam Type ............................... Refelctor type: Wide spot, Optics type: Narrow spot
Beam Characteristics ............... Smooth with slight bluish tint, brighter in center
Throw (Lux) at 1m (click for description) Reflector type (newer) ~ 60 at beam center. (7.75 Comparison Chart equivalent)
Optics type (older) ~ 63 at beam center. (7.92 Comparison Chart equivalent)
Overall Output (click for description) Reflector type (newer)~ 600 (6.00 Comparison Chart equivalent)
Optics type (older)~ 135 (1.35 Comparison Chart equivalent)
Battery / Power Type................ 1 x AA alkaline cell
Battery Life (advertised) ........... 10 hours regulated (Test found > 8 hrs to 50% starting output)
Environmental Protection ......... O-ring seals
Special Items of Note ...............  
Warranty .................................. Limited lifetime
Retail Cost ................................ Original version 19.95 US$ at time of review update at PocketLights.com
New version purchased for 19.95 US$ at Target Dept. Store
 

 

 
TOP OF PAGE       HOME
Legal and Copyright Information     Javascript Menu: Thanks to Milonic.com