Bright Star Trooper II

Provided for review
by the kind folks at:

 
 
3½ Stars
Good/Very Good
         

Light Type: 3 Watt LED
Light Class: Outdoor / Rough Use / Etc.

The Trooper II is a variation on a theme that I've seen a lot lately. Three AAA cells in a carrier powering a 3 Watt LED. *Yawn*... The only unique thing about this light is the fact that the LED is NOT a Luxeon LED, but made by another manufacturer.

Body: The body is pretty common stuff. Anodized aluminum, knurled for grip around the head, body, and tailcap, yadda, yadda, yadda. It uses the now common "post in a ring" system on the tailcap for attachment of the lanyard, but it really can't stand on end well with the lanyard attached anyway. My recommendation: throw the lanyard away. Junk.

Bezel/Head: The head is where it gets a little weird. A number of manufacturers are now creating high powered LEDs. Although the quality doesn't quite compare with Luxeon LEDs, the output is pretty decent. It's not pretty, just pretty decent. In this case the light is bluish with some weird yellowish rings, but more on that later. The reflector is smooth plastic and the lens is plastic as well. The LED sits on a white painted heat sink and the lens on the LED die is of the "low dome" or "batwing" variety for those of you who are interested.

Output: The white light produced by the LED is a high color temperature and produces fair color rendition weighted fairly strongly toward the blue end of the spectrum. The combination of the low dome LED lens and the smooth reflector results in a fairly tight spot but with some strange colored rings - bluish and yellowish alternating - in the beam. It's not all that annoying but it is noticeable. Intensity of output is pretty good, and considering the price (listed below) it isn't bad at all.


Beam at one meter at target center

Runtime Plot: Expect a little less than an hour and a half before you hit 50% of your starting output. This is a typical 3-AAA cell runtime plot. After 3½ hours you'll definitely want to change out the cells. All-in-all, not too shabby.


Runtime completed with Duracell brand batteries. More information on runtime plots is available HERE.

Switch: Another yawn... Typical reverse clickie. Click for on, after it is on you can press for blink. Click again for off. It is fairly well protected from accidental activation by the contour of the head and the body.

Seals / Water Resistance: This light actually has some pretty good seals. Good thick O-rings at all connection points, and you can take the light apart at 3 places - tailcap, tube below the switch, head just above the switch. The O-rings seem to be very slightly lubricated and there is an O-ring just behind the lens.

If it gets wet inside, just disassemble as much a possible without tools and let it dry before using again.

Ergonomics: Very little to mention. The tailcap opens without any difficulty, the switch works fine, and it's too big to really put in your pocket comfortably unless you have really big pockets. Putting batteries in and out of the AAA carrier it has to use is a bit of a pain in the fingernail, but hopefully you won't be changing them out too often.


Size compared to a common 2AA aluminum light

Batteries: Ahhhhh... the lovely little battery carrier. Yuck. I hate these things. Put in two cells + up and one cell + down. Put one in wrong and it won't operate. Break the carrier or lose it and it won't operate either. I know why manufacturers use these things, but I really don't like them. Why do they use them? Because the 4.5V produced by three AAA cells lets you power the LED without adding an expensive-to-develop-and-build boost circuit. I'd much rather they use two AA cells and a boost circuit but that gets pricey. Oh well. It works, and it works just fine in this case.

Accessories: The only accessory is a mandatory-disposable wrist lanyard. Seriously - throw it away. Replace it with something better if you really need a lanyard.

What I Liked: Water resistant, Good battery life, Bright, Easy battery change, Lightweight, Stands up

What I Didn't Like: Unusual color to the beam. Battery carrier.

Picky Little Things: Did I mention the lanyard is crappy? Thought so.

Conclusions: Really not a bad little 3W LED light. Good battery life, good output, good quality and fair design. It's not a junker, but it's not trophy shelf quality either. I'd say it would be good for general household use, car use, tailgating, backyard or car camping, that sort of thing. I wouldn't take it spelunking, hiking, or backwoods camping, but that's just my opinion. Good price, though, for a 3W LED.


Quick Facts Table:

Item Reviewed.......................... Bright Star Trooper II
Review Date ............................. February 2006
Case Material ........................... Anodized Aluminum
Case Features .......................... Checkered for grip
Case Access Type .................... Unscrew Tailcap
Switch Type ............................. Clickie on side below head
Reflector Type ......................... Smooth Silvered Plastic
Lens Type ................................ Plastic
Bulb Type ................................. 3 Watt LED
Beam Type ............................... Spot
Beam Characteristics ............... Bluish with some yellow, ringy
Throw (Lux) at 1m (click for description) ~ 432 at beam center. (20.78 Comparison Chart equivalent)
Overall Output (click for description) ~ 2000 (20.00 Comparison Chart equivalent)
Battery / Power Type................ 3 x AAA cells
Battery Life (advertised) ........... Up to 20 hours
Battery Life (test results) ........... 1 hr 20 min to 50% output
Environmental Protection ......... O-ring seals
Weight (oz.) with batteries ....... 6.2
Special Items of Note ............... Wrist lanyard included
Warranty .................................. Unknown
Retail Cost ................................ 20.95 US$ at time of review at BrightGuy.com
 

 

 
TOP OF PAGE       HOME
Legal and Copyright Information     Javascript Menu: Thanks to Milonic.com