Black Diamond Polar Star

Provided for review
by the kind folks at:

 
 
3 Stars
Good
         

Light Type: Incandescent / LED
Light Class: Outdoor / Rough Use / Etc.

Short Description:

The Polar Star headlamp is made by Black Diamond and is available for purchase from e-Headlamps.com. This particular headlamp is designed for cold-weather adventure.

Like several of the new headlamps from Black Diamond, this headlamp utilizes both an LED and an incandescent bulb in one bezel to provide two levels of light output. LEDs are best utilized for close-up work such as camp chores, while the incandescent bulb can be focused to a tighter beam for walking trails and spotting objects at a distance. There are three different incandescent bulbs that can be used with this headlamp. It comes with a "long life" bulb in the bezel and a "bright" bulb in the battery box. A "superbright" bulb can be purchased separately. The bulbs have different color bases (blue, yellow, red) to indicate their intensity. Increased intensity comes at a cost of reduced battery life.

The entire headlamp is held on the head using a three point elastic support system with the bezel up front. Intended for cold weather use, the battery box is attached to a long cable and comes with a neck strap which allows the battery box to be worn under the clothing to keep it warm. A cable runs over the top of the user's head to connect bezel and the battery box. The two clips that hold the cable can be moved to either of the side elastic straps, allowing the cable to run around the side of the user's head. The switch is located underneath the bezel and allows for selection of the LED or incandescent bulb by clicking in series. The bezel is tilt adjustable for close work. The battery box has a rubber cover which is held closed with a tight elastic strap. The bezel is sealed with rubber grommets and O-rings.

Package
Size Reference
Bezel
Beam Profile - Incandescent
Beam Profile - LED

Detailed Information:

The Black Diamond Polar Star is obviously intended for cold weather use. The separate battery box allows the user to keep the batteries warm under the clothing.

The body of the headlamp is divided into two main parts: the bezel and the battery box. The bezel is made of translucent purple plastic with a rubber focusing ring surrounding the lens. On the top right side of the bezel the cable connecting the bezel to the battery box exits the bezel through a rubber grommet and over the user's head, connected to the strap by two clips. The grommet prevents wear on the cable and also provides a water-resistant seal. The bezel is attached to a plastic forehead plate by a large slotted bolt which will accept a small coin or screwdriver for adjusting the tension of the tilting action. The bezel can be tilted 90 degrees from straight out to straight down. On the back of the plate is a rubber disk which serves as a cushion. The strap runs between the cushion and the head of the user.

Inside the bezel you will find a single LED and the incandescent bulb. The reflector is textured to prevent the appearance of artifacts such as dark splotches in the beam when the light is focused.

Runtime and range vary depending upon which incandescent bulb is placed in the lamp.

Bulb Type
Advertised Range
Advertised Runtime
Long Life
70 meters
7 hours
Bright
100 meters
3.5 hours
Super Bright
140 meters
2.5 hours

The single LED gives a 10 meter range and 1000 hours advertised runtime. There is no regulation circuitry in the headlamp, so output diminishes over time.

To change the incandescent bulb, you simply unscrew the bezel to expose the lamp. To focus the bulb, twist the rubber focus ring to achieve the desired beam. The LED never needs to be changed. The headlamp comes fitted with a "long life" bulb. A spare "bright" bulb is supposed to be included stored in the battery box, but based on the color coding on their website, it appears that a "superbright" bulb may have come in the battery box instead.

The switch is underneath the bezel and is easy to operate with the thumb when grasping the bezel. First click turns the LED on, second click is off, third click turns the incandescent bulb on, and the fourth click turns it off again.

The straps are elastic and are fully adjustable. The strap attachment points on the bezel are slotted so that the straps can be removed for cleaning or replacement.

The battery box is formed from two pieces - a hard plastic outer section which holds the batteries and spare bulb, and a rubber cover which seals the battery compartment. There is a very tight strap that wraps around the battery box and passes through two slots to hold the battery box lid on. To open the battery box it is necessary to either remove the strap or slide the rubber cover out from under the strap. Removing the strap proved very difficult despite the fact that the slots have cuts to allow removal of the strap. If the strap is left on you must work around it as you replace the batteries. After changing the batteries, fit the rubber cover back onto the plastic box and press on it all the way around its edge to ensure a tight seal. Replace the elastic strap if necessary. The headlamp will accept lithium AA 1.5 volt batteries for better cold weather performance.

The battery box is designed to hang around the user's neck from an included strap. The box has 1/2 of a quick release buckle attached to its top by a short strap. The neck strap has the other half. The neck strap also has a quick release buckle for quick removal from the user's neck and is fully adjustable. Likewise, the battery box could just be kept in an inner pocket, foregoing the use of the neck strap.

The light takes 3 AA batteries which are held in the battery box vertically. Batteries are not included.

What I Liked:

I liked the fact that the headlamp is water resistant, has both LED and incandescent in one light, and has multiple incandescent bulb options depending upon your needs. It felt a little strange without the battery box in the back to balance the bezel, but this did make it very comfortable on the neck muscles. The switch on the bottom of the bezel is very easy to operate. Adjusting the tension on the tilt mechanism is very easy.

What I Didn't Like:

Changing the batteries is a huge pain in the butt. Sorry, but there's no easy way to put it. The strap on the battery box doesn't want to come off through the slots in the keepers, so you are left with leaving it in your way as you slide the rubber cover out from underneath it. I can't imagine trying to accomplish a battery change with cold weather gloves on.

Other Things I Noticed:

The focus mechanism for the incandescent bulb is smooth but has very little range. I don't think you'll need to do a lot of focusing since you have the LED for close up work anyway. I would prefer if you could turn the LEDs and incandescent on separately so that you didn't have to cycle through one setting to get to the other, but this is a minor inconvenience.

Conclusions:

For cold weather use, the Polar Star should serve fairly well. If you are not going to be using the headlamp for cold weather sports, consider the Black Diamond Gemini or the Black Diamond Supernova instead.


Quick Facts Table:

Review Date ............................. September 2003
Case Material ........................... Plastic / Rubber
Case Features ..........................  
Case Access Type .................... Loosen Strap, pull off rubber clamshell battery cover
Switch Type ............................. Series click switch
Reflector Type ......................... Textured silver
Lens Type ................................

Plastic

Bulb Type ................................. 2 x white LED, 1 x incandescent bi-pin xenon
Beam Type ............................... Adjustable
Beam Characteristics ............... Slight artifacts when set to wide focus
Throw (Lux) at 1m (click for description) LED: 25, Incand: 371
Overall Output (click for description) LED: 280, Incand: 850
Battery / Power Type................ 3 x AA alkaline or lithium (alkaline included)
Battery Life (advertised) ........... Varies - see table above
Environmental Protection ......... O-rings and seals - splashproof/rainproof
Special Items of Note ...............  
Warranty .................................. 3 Years
Retail Cost ................................ $42.95 US$ at e-Headlamps.com at time of review
 

 

 
TOP OF PAGE       HOME
Legal and Copyright Information     Javascript Menu: Thanks to Milonic.com